Why Did David Lee Roth Leave Van Halen? On Oct. 6, 2020, Eddie Van Halen passed away at 65 years old, after a long battle with throat cancer, reported TMZ. The publication stated his death came after a swift health decline after his cancer had spread to his brain and other areas of his body.
It’s backstage in Vancouver in 1984, and David Lee Roth is having the time of his life. The other band members? Not so much It was Vancouver, May 1984, and Van Halen were in town. One of the biggest bands in the world; their commercial powers, it would seem, having reached hitherto uncharted heights.
He leaves behind a wife and son, and the history of his incredible music career in Van Halen. As people pay tribute and listen to the music of the past, some are wondering: Why did David Lee Roth leave Van Halen, as a founding member of the group? Why did David Lee Roth leave Van Halen when he did?
Van Halen’s 1984 (1984) produced multiple MTV hits and sold over 10-million copies, launching the band into super-stardom. A monstrous world tour capped off what should have been the start of even greater success. But it didn’t. Instead, it marked the end of the Roth-era when David left the band.
When did David Lee Roth go solo?
David Lee Roth was a great self-promoter, and so his going solo in 1985 was probably inevitable. And part of what made him such a great front man was likely what made him and Eddie Van Halen butt heads so often.
One person who was hearing a lot of Eddie’s side of things was Kiss bassist Gene Simmons, who actually got the band their first big break. Eddie kept telling his mentor how he and Roth were increasingly at odds, and around 1982, things apparently got bad enough that Eddie (according to Simmons) began asking to join Kiss. Gene said he persuaded him that it wouldn’t be a good fit. Kiss guitarist Paul Stanley says it never came that close to actually happening, but they both agree that Eddie and David were not getting along at all, and it was becoming public knowledge.
Van Halen’s most famous album is probably 1984 , released that same year. It was also the album where Roth and Eddie Van Halen realized how impossible their relationship had become. This was the first album Eddie and the band completed in their new homemade studio, 5150, and it’s where Eddie stuck it to their longtime producer, Ted Templeman. Eddie wanted no cover tunes, something that Templeman had usually had them include prominently on previous albums. But no, this was Eddie’s album, made in Eddie’s studio.
Van Halen became known for chugging Jack Daniels from the bottle during their shows. There’s even a famous clip of Roth drunkenly addressing the crowd during their infamous US Festival show in 1983, before someone showed up on stage with a bottle of booze for the singer.
Van Halen jumped into the music scene in the late ’70s, and the music scene didn’t quite know what to do with them. Disco was huge, and punk bands considered huge rock bands like Led Zeppelin old hat. Yet the band was so good and so charismatic that they succeeded beyond their wildest dreams.
Though Van Halen’s debut album came out in 1978, their history actually goes back several years before that. They started off in 1972, calling themselves Genesis (which was taken), and then Mammoth. Eddie was actually the lead singer back then, and bassist Michael Anthony had not yet joined the fold. They rented their sound system from a singer in another local L.A.-area band. His name was David Lee Roth. Roth had failed several previous auditions to be the singer in Mammoth but was still renting his PA gear to them for a reported $50 a gig.
Think Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, but with bikinis. Roth even kept Eddie Van Halen in mind to do the soundtrack, before the band folded officially in summer 1985. Eddie would decline the offer. Still, storyboards were drawn up, and a cast was assembled to begin production.
ADVERTISEMENT
When did David Lee Roth quit Van Halen?
One of the biggest shakeups in rock ‘n’ roll history is when David Lee Roth quit Van Halen in 1985. But did he really quit? This insider, who was known as “one of the fifth members of Van Halen,” says David did not quit …. Legend has it that on April 1st, 1985 …. April Fool’s Day ….
Pete held myriad jobs while with Van Halen from 1977-1985 (including lighting director, creative consultant, and video work), and was later one-half of the solo David Lee Roth video team, The Fabulous Picasso Brothers, and can be seen in some of Roth’s solo videos. When the band was dissolving, he was there.
In regard to the early 5150 sessions when Dave was still on board, he had these things to say about the music Eddie was writing: “The music was turning morose. Probably because of individual personal habits more than anything else.” “My choice was to commit poetic felonies, wind up doing melancholy power ballads. No way.” Dave goes on to describe the verbal confrontations between he and Eddie as stopping just short of turning into fisticuffs.
Dave said in his book he left because the brothers didn’t want too work and were more interested in drinking. I’ll believe him over ANYONE involved with the band back then until he says otherwise. He said he told Ed maybe they can reconvene at another time.
With all groups, there is some tension between the members. In 1985 , when they announced the break-up, I was with Dave actually at the time. As I remember it, they had been touring pretty consistently for five years. And the idea was simply to take like a year hiatus. And some of them had things they were interested in doing during that year. Dave wanted to spend the time to make a movie [Pete and Dave were collaborating on a movie, Crazy from the Heat, which was never filmed].
It didn’t even happen in April. But it was during April that the band (read, Eddie and Alex) decided to fire their longtime personal manager, Noel Monk, very much against the pleas of David Lee Roth. So, April 1985 saw the band without management for the first time since its club days.
Usually, both sides …. Roth and Van Halen … will describe the breakup as Roth simply leaving the band. But we think it wasn’t a black-or-white, he-quit-or-didn’t-quit situation.
Why did David Lee Roth leave Van Halen?
While it may be unclear who’s to blame, one thing is certain. David Lee Roth left Van Halen and fans were left wondering what might have been.
Eddie Van Halen and David Lee Roth taking a small break on their 1984 tour. Image Credit: Flickr. It is during this time that Eddie began to question the future of Van Halen.
Their album Van Halen (1978) took the rock world by storm. It became one of the most successful debut albums in the genre. This was followed by a successful tour that saw the band’s popularity grow due to the energetic on-stage persona of Roth and ear-shattering playing of Eddie.
Van Halen’s 1984 (1984) produced multiple MTV hits and sold over 10-million copies, launching the band into super-stardom. A monstrous world tour capped off what should have been the start of even greater success. But it didn’t. Instead, it marked the end of the Roth-era when David left the band.
Eddie Van Halen and David Lee Roth taking a small break on their 1984 tour. Image Credit: Flickr
Then, in 1985, the wave came crashing down with the departure of the group’s lead singer during the high water mark of success left by the album 1984. David Lee Roth left Van Halen, leaving countless fans wondering why. Van Halen rose from obscurity …
During a meeting with Eddie, he expressed that he could no longer work with the group. David Lee Roth’s new band included Greg Bissonette, Steve Vai, and Billy Sheehan.
